How the Student Aid Index (SAI) Will Impact College Affordability.
The formula for determining financial aid eligibility for college just got an overhaul, with the Expected Family Contribution (EFC) measure now replaced by the Student Aid Index (SAI). This new metric aims to provide a more realistic picture of college affordability for families.
The EFC, calculated through a complex formula using the information on the FAFSA form, was often misinterpreted as the amount parents would pay out-of-pocket. However many faced higher unmet costs. The more neutrally termed SAI accounts for both family contributions and overall college expenses to determine need-based aid.
Decoding the New Formula
In simple terms, the formula is:
Cost of Attendance (COA)
- Student Aid Index (SAI)
- Other aid/scholarships = Financial Need
The SAI amalgamates family income, assets, size, and other inputs to estimate household contributions. Subtracting SAI from the college’s COA gives an initial financial need used to allocate need-based aid.
For example, if College A's COA is $35,000 and a student's SAI is $5,000, her initial need is $30,000. If she receives a $10,000 outside scholarship, her remaining need is $20,000, which the college tries to meet through grants, federal loans, work-study, etc.
Why Was This Change Needed?
The shift aims to provide a more nuanced perspective on affordability. Reliance on the EFC caused several problems:
- Families often assumed EFC represented the total cost for them. But unmet needs meant real out-of-pocket costs were higher.
- Colleges could manipulate COA to seem affordable on paper based on a family’s EFC when real costs were higher.
- EFC penalized families with any college savings by expecting higher contributions. SAI excludes assets like 529 plans from the formula.
- EFC changes fostered confusion by making year-over-year comparisons difficult. SAI methodology will remain constant.
What Does This Mean for Families?
The SAI brings both positive and negative implications:
Potential Benefits:
- Presents a more realistic picture of college costs for families
- Helps identify affordable colleges aligned with their budget
- Reduces penalization for families who have saved for college
- Simplifies year-over-year comparisons of aid packages
Potential Drawbacks:
- This may increase anxiety for low-income families by highlighting the full costs
- Does not guarantee sufficient grant aid will be provided
- Continues complexity of assessing affordability amid opaque college pricing
- Still allows colleges to use loans to meet needs, impeding access
While the SAI represents an improvement, it isn’t a silver bullet. Affordability barriers will persist. Families must still scrutinize aid offers closely, apply strategically, and weigh costs versus long-term outcomes. Open conversations about family budgets and priorities remain essential in navigating the ongoing challenges of paying for college.
What is the Student Aid Index?
The SAI replaces the EFC in estimating families’ ability to pay for college. It amalgamates inputs like income, assets, and household size into a dollar amount used to allocate need-based aid like grants and subsidized loans.
A major impetus for the change was families often misinterpreted the EFC as their total out-of-pocket payment when real costs were higher. The SAI provides a more nuanced perspective on affordability.
Streamlined FAFSA Form
Under the FAFSA Simplification Act, the form is now shorter, with fewer questions. This saves time for families applying for aid.
Updates to Cost of Attendance
Colleges calculate the Cost of Attendance (COA) to estimate full annual expenses. Changes impacting SAI include:
- Allowances for purchasing a computer regardless of enrollment status
- New transportation allowances between home, school, and work
- Splitting room and board into separate cost items
- Mandatory fees for federal student loans
These could increase COA at some colleges, highlighting true costs.
Impact on Multiple Students
Previously, families got some relief when multiple children attended college. However, the SAI will no longer be divided, potentially increasing the burden on middle- and high-income parents.
Expanded Pell Grant Eligibility
More students will qualify for Pell Grants based on the poverty line. Incarcerated students can also access grants, improving equity.
Negative SAI Allowed
For the neediest students eligible for maximum Pell Grants, SAI is set to zero. However, the formula can yield negative SAI, further increasing aid eligibility.
The SAI Chart provides rough estimates based on income and family size. However, many factors influence the final SAI, so families should use FAFSA4caster or net price calculators to model scenarios.
While the SAI brings needed improvements, college affordability challenges remain. Families must still scrutinize aid offers, apply strategically across colleges, and weigh costs versus outcomes. Open communication about family budgets and values can help identify the best fit.
Here is the table for the 2024-2045 SAI Chart
| AGI | 1 Dependent | 2 Dependents | 3 Dependents | 4 Dependents |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $30,000 | $0 | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| $32,500 | $0 | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| $35,000 | $0 | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| $37,500 | $0 | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| $40,000 | $0 | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| $42,500 | $1,680 | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| $45,000 | $2,122 | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| $47,500 | $2,564 | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| $50,000 | $3,066 | $1,504 | $0 | $0 |
| $52,500 | $3,448 | $2,387 | $0 | $0 |
| $55,000 | $3,890 | $2,387 | $0 | $0 |
| $57,500 | $4,332 | $2,829 | $1,410 | $0 |
| $60,000 | $4,774 | $3,271 | $1,852 | $0 |
| $62,500 | $5,216 | $3,713 | $2,294 | $0 |
| $65,000 | $5,703 | $4,155 | $2,736 | $0 |
| $67,500 | $6,205 | $4,597 | $3,178 | $1,598 |
| $70,000 | $6,752 | $5,039 | $3,620 | $2,040 |
| $72,500 | $7,334 | $5,502 | $4,062 | $2,482 |
| $75,000 | $7,953 | $6,004 | $4,504 | $2,924 |
| $80,000 | $9,334 | $7,101 | $5,396 | $3,808 |
| $85,000 | $10,883 | $8,314 | $6,364 | $4,660 |
| $90,000 | $12,517 | $9,558 | $7,374 | $5,448 |
| $95,000 | $14,170 | $10,965 | $8,513 | $6,328 |
| $100,000 | $15,824 | $12,614 | $9,792 | $7,332 |
| $105,000 | $17,477 | $14,267 | $11,235 | $8,463 |
| $110,000 | $19,130 | $15,920 | $12,889 | $9,734 |
| $115,000 | $20,783 | $17,573 | $14,542 | $11,167 |
| $120,000 | $22,437 | $19,227 | $16,195 | $12,820 |
| $125,000 | $24,090 | $20,880 | $17,848 | $14,474 |
| $130,000 | $25,743 | $22,533 | $19,501 | $16,127 |
| $135,000 | $27,396 | $24,186 | $21,155 | $17,780 |
| $140,000 | $29,050 | $25,839 | $22,808 | $19,433 |
| $145,000 | $30,703 | $27,493 | $24,461 | $21,087 |
| $150,000 | $32,356 | $29,146 | $26,114 | $22,740 |
| $155,000 | $34,009 | $30,799 | $27,768 | $24,393 |
| $160,000 | $35,662 | $32,452 | $29,421 | $26,046 |
| $165,000 | $37,316 | $34,106 | $31,074 | $27,699 |
| $170,000 | $38,969 | $35,759 | $32,727 | $29,353 |
| $175,000 | $40,622 | $37,412 | $34,380 | $31,006 |
| $180,000 | $42,258 | $39,048 | $36,016 | $32,642 |
| $185,000 | $43,864 | $40,654 | $37,623 | $34,248 |
| $190,000 | $45,470 | $42,260 | $39,229 | $35,854 |
| $195,000 | $47,077 | $43,867 | $40,835 | $37,460 |
| $200,000 | $48,683 | $45,473 | $42,441 | $39,067 |
| $205,000 | $50,289 | $47,079 | $44,047 | $40,673 |
| $210,000 | $51,895 | $48,685 | $45,654 | $42,279 |
| $215,000 | $53,502 | $50,291 | $47,260 | $43,885 |
| $220,000 | $55,108 | $51,898 | $48,866 | $45,492 |
| $225,000 | $56,714 | $53,504 | $50,572 | $47,098 |
| $230,000 | $58,320 | $55,110 | $52,079 | $48,708 |
| $235,000 | $59,926 | $56,716 | $53,685 | $50,310 |
| $240,000 | $61,533 | $58,323 | $55,291 | $51,196 |
| $245,000 | $63,139 | $59,929 | $56,879 | $53,523 |
| $250,000 | $64,745 | $61,535 | $58,503 | $55,129 |
| $275,000 | $72,776 | $69,566 | $66,535 | $63,160 |
| $300,000 | $80,982 | $77,772 | $74,741 | $71,366 |
Observations on How the Student Aid Index Formula Impacts Aid Eligibility
With the transition from the Expected Family Contribution (EFC) to the new Student Aid Index (SAI), families wonder how this formula change will impact their eligibility for need-based financial aid. Analyzing the updated SAI charts and formula provides some insights.
Revised Pell Grant Formulas
Beyond the SAI, eligibility for Pell Grants is now calculated using different formulas tied to the poverty line, rather than EFC. Minimum Pell awards start at 275% of poverty guidelines, while maximum awards are available up to 175% of poverty.
Lower SAI Than Past Years, But Higher Than 2023-2024
Comparing SAI figures to EFC amounts in 2017-2022 shows lower index values now. However, they exceed EFC levels in 2023-2024 for incomes above approximately $50,000.
Eliminating the state tax allowance deduction from the formula leads to higher SAI results than expected over past projections. But the impact is reduced at lower incomes.
Impact of Family Size on SAI
Each additional child appears to decrease a family’s SAI by around $3,000. This reflects the formula accounting for more dependents reducing available household contributions.
For example, a family with one child and $60,000 income has a $4,774 SAI. With two children, their SAI drops to $3,271. The additional dependent lowered SAI by $1,503.
Effect of Income Changes on SAI
Above approximately $80,000 in Adjusted Gross Income (AGI), every extra $10,000 in earnings seems to raise SAI by about $3,000. However, between $30,000 to $80,000, the SAI increase per $10,000 of income is smaller, averaging $1,750 to $2,750.
So a boost from $70,000 to $80,000 AGI increases SAI by around $2,750 for one child. But going from $150,000 to $160,000 AGI raises SAI by $3,000. Lower-income families see smaller SAI hikes per extra $10,000 earned.
What This Means for Financial Aid Eligibility
The observations indicate:
- More dependents significantly lower families’ SAI, improving aid chances.
- But income hikes now more steeply raise SAI, eroding aid eligibility faster once over $80,000.
- The “income protection allowance” shelters less income from SAI than before.
- Families just above $80,000 AGI face a “cliff” with disproportionate SAI jumps.
In summary, the SAI formula tweaks create winners and losers. Larger families benefit, but aid declines faster for incomes over $80,000. Lower-middle-class families in the $60,000 to $100,000 range may see the toughest trade-offs from a less favorable SAI curve.
Scrutinizing the formula and estimating your individual SAI is essential to assess potential changes in aid eligibility. The SAI charts provide only general guidance. All families should use net price calculators and the FAFSA4caster to model their unique situation. While imperfect, the SAI aims to better reflect the financial realities families face in paying for college.
1 thought on “SAI: How the Student Aid Index (SAI) Will Impact College Affordability.”