Comparing 15-Year and 30-Year Mortgages: Pros and Cons

Table of Contents hide
1 15-Year vs. 30-Year Mortgage: In-Depth Comparison of Pros, Cons, and Key Factors

15-Year vs. 30-Year Mortgage: In-Depth Comparison of Pros, Cons, and Key Factors

One of the biggest decisions when obtaining a mortgage is choosing between a 15-year or 30-year loan term. This comprehensive guide examines the key differences, pros and cons, and factors to consider when deciding between 15-year and 30-year mortgages.

Key TakeawaysMortgages

  • 15-year mortgages offer faster payoff, lower rates, and total interest paid, but require higher monthly payments
  • 30-year mortgages provide affordability through lower payments but you pay more interest over the full loan term
  • Carefully weigh your budget, financial priorities, life stage, and other factors when choosing between 15 and 30-year mortgage or home loans
  • Use a mortgage calculator to estimate how interest costs and payments differ between the two terms based on your personalized loan details

Mortgage Term Overview

The loan term refers to the length of time over which you repay your mortgage. Traditional fixed-rate mortgages are offered in 15-year and 30-year terms:

15-Year Mortgage

  • A loan is paid off in 180 monthly payments (15 years)
  • Faster repayment means you build equity quicker
  • Reduced Interest Rate and Decreased Total Interest Payments
  • Higher monthly payments

30-Year Mortgage

  • A loan is repaid in 360 monthly payments (30 years)
  • Lower monthly payments but pay more total interest
  • Slower equity buildup over the life of the loan
  • Flexibility to make extra payments as budget allows

Choosing the right loan term depends on your financial situation, priorities, and goals. Carefully consider both the advantages and disadvantages before making your decision.

Key Factors When Comparing 15-Year vs. 30-Year Mortgages

Consider these key factors when evaluating 15-year versus 30-year mortgage loans:

Mortgage Interest Rates

  • 15-Year – Tend to have lower interest rates, often 0.25-0.5% below 30-year rates. You pay less interest at a lower rate.
  • 30-YearHigher interest rates than 15-year loans, but the difference is usually fairly small.

Mortgage Monthly Payments

  • 15-YearHigher monthly payments since the loan is repaid faster. Payments can be $300-500+ more per month than a 30-year mortgage.
  • 30-YearLower monthly payments, making it easier to qualify and fit mortgage into your budget.

Total Interest Paid

  • 15-Year – Much less interest paid over the full loan term since the loan is shorter. Interest paid can be 50-70% less than a 30-year loan.
  • 30-YearMore total interest due to a longer repayment period. You pay interest for 15 more years.

Mortgage Total Cost

  • 15-YearLower total cost over the life of the mortgage thanks to lower interest charges.
  • 30-YearHigher total cost – you pay more interest so the total loan amount is larger.

Loan Qualification for Mortgage

  • 15-Year – Need to qualify for higher monthly payment. A lower debt-to-income ratio helps approval odds.
  • 30-Year – Easier to qualify thanks to lower monthly payments. Good option if affordability is a concern.

Mortgage – Loan-to-Value (LTV)

  • 15-Year – Reach 20% equity faster to eliminate PMI insurance.
  • 30-Year – Slower equity buildup means more years paying PMI premiums.

Pros of 15-Year Mortgages

1. Pay off the Mortgage Faster

Completing repayment in 15 years allows you to pay off your home loan much quicker. This provides a sense of accomplishment and accelerates your transition to owning your home free and clear.

2. Accumulate Home Equity Faster

Faster repayment builds equity in your home at a quicker rate. You can leverage home equity for financing needs in less time.

3. Save Substantially on Interest

You pay much less interest with a 15-year term thanks to lower rates and fewer years. This saves tens of thousands over a 30-year mortgage.

4. Own your Home Sooner

Owning your home outright in 15 years gives peace of mind and satisfaction. You also reduce living expenses earlier by eliminating your mortgage payment entirely.

5. Eliminate Mortgage Insurance Sooner

When you reach 20% equity by paying down your mortgage balance faster, you can request the removal of private mortgage insurance (PMI) premiums sooner.

Cons of 15-Year Mortgages

Higher Monthly Payments

15-year mortgages require higher monthly payments to repay the loan on the accelerated schedule. This stretches the budget for some borrowers.

More Difficult to Qualify

You must be able to afford the higher monthly payment. Lower debt-to-income ratios improve qualification chances.

Less Financial Flexibility

Less wiggle room in the monthly budget to absorb income disruptions or unexpected costs. Refinancing may be needed to extend the term if payments become unaffordable.

Opportunity Cost of Extra Money Toward the Mortgage

Money going toward higher monthly payments could potentially be invested at a higher return instead of paying down low-rate mortgage debt.

Penalties for Early PayOff

You may face prepayment penalties if you sell or refinance your home in the first few years of repayment, adding to your costs.

Pros of 30-Year Mortgages

Lower Monthly Payments

The longer repayment term results in lower monthly mortgage payments. This helps qualification and improves affordability.

Easier Approval with Lower Income/Debt

The lower monthly costs increase approval odds for borrowers with tighter budgets or high existing debts.

Added Budget Flexibility

Lower payments free up monthly cash flow for other expenses and goals. Allows budget room in case of disruptions to income.

Ability to Pay Ahead Voluntarily

You can choose to make extra principal payments when possible to pay off the loan faster while maintaining lower required monthly payments.

Lower Opportunity Cost

Less money is tied up in mortgage principal, allowing more funds for other investments that may outearn mortgage interest rate returns.

Cons of 30-Year Mortgages

More Interest Paid over Loan Life

Extending the repayment period for 15 more years results in substantially higher total interest costs.

Slower Equity Accumulation

It takes longer to build home equity that can be tapped for other needs. PMI premiums also typically last longer.

Longer Time Until Mortgage Freedom

Owning your home free and clear takes twice as long. Retirement planning may require factoring mortgage payments further into the future.

Greater Interest Rate Risk

Paying interest for 30 years carries a higher risk of interest rates rising over the life of your loan through economic cycles.

More Interest rate Sensitivity

With a lower monthly payment, more of your payment goes toward interest. So when rates rise, more of your larger 30-year payment is consumed.

Key Factors When Deciding Between 15-Year and 30-Year Mortgages

Consider the following factors when determining if a 15-year or 30-year mortgage better aligns with your financial situation and goals:

  • Budget – Will the higher 15-year payment fit, or does a 30-year term provide needed affordability?
  • Life stage – Are you early or later in your homeownership journey? repaying sooner may be appealing closer to retirement.
  • Income stability – Steady income supports a 15-year mortgage, while variable income favors a 30-year for flexibility.
  • Down payment – The more equity upfront, the less long-term interest you pay, favoring a 15-year mortgage.
  • Time in a home – If you may move sooner, 15-year mortgages help limit interest paid and build equity faster.
  • Financial priorities – 15 years best if debt freedom is your priority. 30-years offer flexibility if investing or other goals take precedence.
  • Interest rates – When rates are very low, 15-year mortgages to lock in savings make sense.

15-Year vs. 30-Year Mortgage Calculator

A mortgage calculator allows you to compare projected monthly payments, lifetime interest, and total costs between 15-year and 30-year loans personalized to your scenario.

For example, on a $300,000 mortgage amount at 6% interest:
Loan TermMonthly PaymentTotal InterestTotal Cost

You can see how the 15-year mortgage saves over $120,000 in interest and has a much lower total cost but at the expense of a $600 higher monthly payment.

Refinancing From 30-Year to 15-Year Mortgage

Many opt for a 30-year mortgage initially for lower payments but later refinance to a 15-year term once the budget allows. This combines flexibility upfront with interest savings long-term.

Factors to weigh when refinancing to a 15-year mortgage:

  • Compare new 15-year rates vs. your existing 30-year rate – refinance when you can get at least a 0.75% lower rate
  • Ensure you can afford the increased monthly payment
  • Evaluate closing costs – aim to recoup costs within 2-3 years of refinancing via lower interest
  • Consider timing – best when you plan to stay at home beyond the breakeven point

Alternatives to 15-Year and 30-Year Mortgages

Beyond standard 15 and 30-year fixed mortgages, some other options to consider include:

  • 10-Year Mortgage – Further accelerated payoff and interest savings but highest monthly payment
  • 20-Year Mortgage – Middle ground between 15 and 30-year terms
  • ARMs – Lower initial rates with interest fluctuations over time; risk of payment spikes
  • 40-Year Mortgage – Extended repayment for affordability; much more interest paid
  • Balloon Mortgage – Low payments for a set time but large final payment due; risky for borrowers

For many borrowers, 15 or 30-year fixed mortgages are the optimal choice for a balance of affordability, stability, and reasonable term length.

15-Year vs. 30-Year Mortgage FAQs

What is the Most Popular Mortgage Term?

The 30-year fixed mortgage is the most common thanks to its affordability. Around 90% of mortgage borrowers opt for a 30-year loan.

Are 15-year Mortgage Rates always Lower?

In general, 15-year loans offer rates around 0.25-0.5% lower. But sometimes 30-year rates can dip slightly below 15-year rates in unique market conditions.

Can you get a 20-year Mortgage?

Yes, 20-year mortgages are less common but offer a middle ground between 15 and 30-year loans. They combine relatively low monthly payments with strong interest savings.

Is it smart to get a 30-year Mortgage and pay it like a 15-year?

This is a savvy strategy providing the budget flexibility of a 30-year term while saving substantially on interest by making the higher 15-year payment if affordable.

How much more Interest is Paid on a 30-year Mortgage?

For a median $300,000 loan amount, total interest paid over the full term is typically $50,000-100,000+ higher compared to a 15-year mortgage.

When does it make sense to Choose a 15-year Mortgage?

If you plan a shorter hold period, want to build equity quickly, value interest savings highly, have sufficient income, and low rate environment.

Does a 15-year Mortgage Always have a Lower Rate?

In most cases yes, but in rare instances 30-year rates can dip slightly below 15 years for certain lenders. On average, expect around a 0.25-0.5% lower rate for 15-year loans.

Can I pay my 30-year Mortgage like a 15-year later?

Yes, you can choose to make extra principal payments on a 30-year mortgage at any point to pay it off faster like a 15-year term, providing flexibility.

Should I get a 15 or 30-year Mortgage in Retirement?

In retirement, consider a 15-year term if possible to pay off the mortgage faster and eliminate payments to stretch retirement savings. But a 30-year provides room in the budget for other living expenses.

How much lower are Mortgage Payments on a 30-year vs. 15-year?

For the same loan amount, monthly payments are typically around $250-500 lower for a 30-year mortgage in comparison to a 15-year loan.

This comprehensive mortgage term guide examines the pros, cons, key factors, and alternatives to help you make an informed 15-year versus 30-year mortgage decision. In the comment section below, please let me know if you have any other questions!

Leave a Comment